Saving the Marsh
Los Angeles Times
August 6, 2006
Postcard from Parchester Village
By Aleta George, Aleta George is a columnist for Bay Nature magazine.
Whitney Dotson was 5 years old when he moved into the brand-new
house his father bought on Jenkins Way in Parchester Village.
It was the early 1950s, and the planned 420-house development
was Richmond's first subdivision in which an African American
could buy a home.
Nestled into a wide cove of San Francisco Bay, Parchester offered
a welcome mix of open space, isolation and community, even though
it was plopped down in an industrial landscape.
All the backyards on Jenkins Way—a long street with small,
densely packed, flat-roofed homes—butt up against a 15-foot
berm. On top of the berm, Southern Pacific freight cars hurl
through space and shake the houses. Whitney's mother, Mary Lee,
who at 83 still lives in the neighborhood, kept her young kids
away from the trains because everyone knew that a man named Jackson
was killed on the tracks in Seaport, the community where they
lived before coming to Parchester.
For three years, Whitney didn't know what was on the other side
of that berm. But at age 8, he and his brother Richard and a
group of their friends got up the gumption to set out and explore.
"That's when the Davy Crockett thing was happening," recalls
Whitney, who was one of many American boys to sport the raccoon-skin
"They had to have the hat now," says Mary Lee. "They'd be hollering,
'Davy, Davy Crockett,' marching up and down the street with them
Their wilderness was no different from Davy's—or so they
imagined. They trekked north to explore the fringes of Giant
Powder Co., the first corporation in America to produce dynamite.
They hiked east to Tank Farm Hill, where about 50 gas and oil
tanks dominated the open grasslands like forts. They built a
raft and, in ponds filled with shattered glass created by foundry
waste, bravely fought off Indian pirates. And nothing could keep
them from going across the tracks. But first, like Crockett,
they put an ear to the rail to see if a locomotive was coming.
A vibration against their ears meant "TRAIN!"
On the other side, Whitney and his friends discovered an expanse
of richly textured marsh, green and lush in summer. Tidal sloughs
snaked their cool, clear way out to the bay. Sea gulls, ospreys
and avocets banked sharply in the marine air, and the pickleweed
underfoot smelled awful. They didn't know the names of the birds,
nor did they have environmental classes to teach them why the
water in the channels rose and fell.
Having never heard the word "marsh," they just called it "over
the tracks," and in sun or fog they swam in the tidal channels
and stomped through the glistening salt grass in the yellow boots
that Mary Lee bought for them. They caught tadpoles in jars and
watched them turn to frogs, running to their treasures first
thing in the morning to see how the creatures had changed overnight.
Come early spring, Mary Lee would go to the fields surrounding
the marsh to gather wild mustard and turnip greens. "They were
nice and tender, because they were out there in the cold," she
says. "Oh, it was good, good. Everyone would come and eat. The
menfolk would barbecue goat. Course I don't like barbecue goat,
but a lot of people do."
Mary Lee grew up in Mossville, La., where the oak trees streamed
with so much moss that the older generation dried it in the sun
and stuffed it into mattresses and pillows. At 15, she married
Richard Daniel Dotson, and in the mid-1940s they left the South
for California with three children in tow and one on the way.
(Whitney was their first California-born child.)
Like most of the other 500,000 African Americans who made the
exodus to California between 1942 and 1945, it wasn't merely
the pull of employment that sent them on their way, but also
the push of Jim Crow and racially motivated violence. "It was
pretty treacherous around there for men," Mary Lee says. "They
didn't have no good time in Louisiana, not the part we lived
And so Parchester became a refuge. And within that refuge, the
marsh became its own sanctuary—one of the last pockets
of pristine tidal land along the bay.
Whitney's father, the Rev. Richard Daniel Dotson, and other local
ministers had tried to make sure that the area past the berm
would be protected as open space. They had shaken hands on the
deal with Fred Parr, a local white developer who had built Parchester
after getting assurances from the ministers that their congregations
would buy new homes there.
But in the decades to follow, the pressure to pave the area,
known as Breuner Marsh, became unrelenting. In the mid-1970s,
Whitney's father and others successfully fought off a municipal
airport intended for the marsh and launched a plan to transform
the adjacent Giant Powder Co. property into a park. It is now
the site of the Point Pinole Regional Shoreline.
More recently, developers have unfurled blueprints for several
housing and light-industrial tracts in the marsh. The Parchester
Village Neighborhood Council—where Whitney serves as president,
just like his dad did—urged the East Bay Regional Park
District to buy the land and add it to the Point Pinole Regional
Shoreline. The developers declined the offer.
But in March, the neighborhood council got the word that it has
been seeking for half a century: The park district board voted
to acquire by eminent domain 218 of the 238 acres of the marsh.
Whitney is especially proud—and relieved. After living
in Louisiana for 13 years, he had moved back to Parchester in
1996 to take care of his father, who died two years ago. A public
health consultant with a master's degree from UC Berkeley, he's
now helping to care for Mary Lee.
"My whole early life experience has been on the shoreline," he
says, his gaze turned toward a great blue heron's stillness. "Everyone
should have a place like this to go."
Now it looks as if they'll have the chance to.